• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Jon Luskin, CFP® ● Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors

Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors

  • Home
  • About
  • Work with Jon
  • Blog
  • Bogleheads® Live
  • Publications
  • Speaking
  • Reading List

Endowment Investing Case Study: Ball State University

October 13, 2017 By Jon Luskin 3 Comments

For my master’s thesis, I explored the investment performance of several multi-million dollar endowment portfolios. In eight case studies, the results consistently showed that a low-cost portfolio outperformed a portfolio paying high fees to access active managers and alternative asset classes. Moreover, risk-adjusted performance showed the low-cost portfolio simply did better. (Previous analysis has shown that a low-cost portfolio outperforms the average endowment.)

But, that was only eight case studies. Why not do more? Enter a series of blog posts evaluating the performance of university endowments.

Ball State University

I first learned about Ball State University and the Ball State University Foundation at the Evidence-Based Investing Conference in Dana Point, California. When Chief Investment Officer Tom Heck explained the foundation’s approach to investing, I knew that there could be a better way.

Fortunately, my hunch about the foundation served me correctly. I pulled Ball State Foundation’s annual report to evaluate their numbers, and I created a proxy portfolio as a benchmark. I discovered that utilizing a low-cost investment strategy could have generated the Ball State University Foundation an extra $60,000,000 over the last ten years.

Massive, undeniable performance via a low-cost investment portfolio.
Massive, undeniable outperformance via a low-cost investment portfolio.

You do not need me to tell you that $60,000,0000 is a lot of money. Given how the foundation designates its assets, $60,000,000 in extra assets would mean an extra $24,000,000 just for student financial assistance alone! That $24,000,000 equates to 257 students being able to attend Ball State University for free – no cost for tuition, not a penny spent on books, nothing for room and board. That’s 257 lives touched – young people who, armed with an education, can go out to make a difference in the world.

Of course, you know that the last 10 years won’t reflect the next ten years. The point here is to showcase the impact of fees – and how reducing those fees could very well mean more people helped.

Bad Benchmarks

It’s simply undeniable that the performance of the Ball State University Foundation is lacking. However, if you were on an onlooker – and not an investment nerd – you may think that the Ball State University Foundation portfolio is doing just fine. Why’s that? Because the annual report for the Foundation showed a benchmark that performed inline with the foundation’s investment portfolio.

If you use a poor performing benchmark, your performance doesn't look so bad.
If you use a poor performing benchmark, your performance doesn’t look so bad.

What’s wrong with Ball State University Foundation’s benchmark? Bad bonds. By opting for a global bond index, the bonds considered ran the gamut on quality. And when it comes to bonds, there is only one bond that offers the quality you want in your portfolio:  United States Treasuries.

So, while Ball State University Foundation held bonds other than U.S. Treasuries, it shouldn’t have. As such, their performance suffered. And by not considering a United States Treasury Index in reporting, they likely didn’t know just how poorly they were performing.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Is a One-Day Financial Review Right for You?

Get Your Free Assessment ➔

Get in Touch with Jon Luskin, CFP®

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Sign Up for New Blog Posts & Podcasts Delivered to Your Inbox

What I’m Reading Right Now

Recent Posts

  • Bogleheads® Live 40: Sean Mullaney on Recent Tax Law Changes for FIRE
  • Bogleheads® Live 39: Protecting Your Income
  • Bogleheads® Live 38: Medicare Questions Answered
  • Bogleheads® Live 37: Christine Benz on ‘How much can I spend in retirement?’
  • Bogleheads® Live 36: Mike Piper on ‘After the Death of Your Spouse’

Categories

  • Bogleheads® Live
  • Bonds
  • College Planning
  • Financial Planning
  • FIRE, FI, Early Retirement
  • Investing
  • Practice Management
  • Real Estate Investing
  • Tax Planning

Jon Luskin, CFP® Follow

Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors. '@Bogleheads® Live' host. Advice-Only #CFP®. #fiduciary. @SDFLC volunteer. Tweets ≠ Advice. https://t.co/GJqMxem3Cr

JonLuskin
jonluskin Jon Luskin, CFP® @jonluskin ·
10 Feb

How to Buy Life #Insurance: Laddering Life Insurance Policies

Instead of buying a single life insurance policy with a term similar to the balance of your working career and the total coverage needed were you to die tomorrow, you could consider laddering policies.

1/n

Reply on Twitter 1624151247186976776 Retweet on Twitter 1624151247186976776 Like on Twitter 1624151247186976776 4 Twitter 1624151247186976776
Retweet on Twitter Jon Luskin, CFP® Retweeted
bogleheads John C Bogle Center for Financial Literacy @bogleheads ·
10 Feb

Mark your calendars for Thursday, 12:00 p.m. Pacific / 3:00 p.m. Eastern.

Will be answering your questions about the critical insurance coverage that is disability #insurance.

Set a reminder for my upcoming Space! https://twitter.com/i/spaces/1OyKAVAlnXqGb

Reply on Twitter 1624088094415933440 Retweet on Twitter 1624088094415933440 1 Like on Twitter 1624088094415933440 1 Twitter 1624088094415933440
jonluskin Jon Luskin, CFP® @jonluskin ·
10 Feb

It’s hard to make a case for any life #insurance that isn’t term life insurance.

Said differently:

Generally, run screaming from whole life, universal life, indexed universal life (IUL), variable life, variable universal life, or anything not term life insurance.

Reply on Twitter 1624060620948529154 Retweet on Twitter 1624060620948529154 1 Like on Twitter 1624060620948529154 37 Twitter 1624060620948529154
Load More

Is the One-Day Financial Review right for you?


Get Your Free Assessment ➔

Disclosures & Legal

Jon Luskin is a registered investment adviser in the states of Arizona, California, Florida, Louisiana, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Texas, Virginia and Washington. The Adviser may not transact business in states where it is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration. Currently, there are no states where the adviser is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration – allowing the adviser to work with anyone in any state. Individualized responses to persons that involve either the effecting of transaction in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation, will not be made without registration or exemption.

Copyright © 2023