• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Jon Luskin, CFP® ● Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors

Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors

  • Home
  • About
  • Work with Jon
  • Blog
  • Bogleheads® Live
  • Publications
  • Speaking
  • Reading List

Why High-Yield Bonds Don’t Make Sense

May 20, 2018 By Jon Luskin 4 Comments

I remember when I was first learning about investing. I was having a conversation with another advisor about high-yield bonds. His approach went something like this:

Live off the coupon! If you hold the high-yield bonds forever, who cares if the bonds fluctuate in value!?

Don’t Evaluate Assets in Isolation

The above logic is rife with problems. Most obviously, high-yield bonds do far more than fluctuate in value. They can (and tend to) outright default. (This means you lose your entire investment, forever!)

Also, high-yield bonds love to sink in value at the same time stocks lose money – making high-yield bonds a poor diversifier against equities.

But, another massive fail in this line of reasoning for high-yield bonds – and the subject of this post – is that it makes no sense to evaluate the performance of high-yield bonds (or any investment) in insolation of your other investments. Since this is so important – and the subject of this blog post – let’s say it again:

Consider all your investments together – and not each investment in isolation.

A nerd once asked, “Are corporate bonds better than U.S. government bonds?” It doesn’t matter. That’s because no one puts 100% of their money into any single investment! (Or at least they shouldn’t!)

Evaluating Performance of an Investment in Isolation Yields the Wrong Answer

What happens when you evaluate an investment on its own merits – and not when combined with other investments to create a diversified portfolio? You get a misleading answer.

Let’s use high-yield bonds as an example. Compare high-yield bonds to Treasury bonds. Of course, high-yield bonds offer more money than Treasuries. As an investor, you have historically been rewarded with a greater investment return by enduring the greater risk of high-yield bonds over Treasuries. (If you’re a nerd, the greater risk in exchange for the greater return of lower-rated bonds is called the “credit premium” or “default premium.”)

 

Index, 1/1/1984-12/31/2017 Return,

Yearly

Bloomberg Barclays U.S. High Yield Bond Index Intermediate 8.62%
Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Treasury Bond Index Intermediate 7.30%

Evaluate Investments on their Inclusion in a Diversified Portfolio

So, if you’re looking to juice the investment return of your portfolio, you should opt for high-yield bonds, right? Not quite.

Though junk bonds may offer a higher investment return than Treasuries, most investors don’t invest in bonds in a vacuum. Normally, bonds are used as part of a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds.

So, what happens when you add both types of these two distinct bonds to U.S. stocks to create a diversified portfolio?

See spiffy-looking pretty chart above. The performance of a portfolio holding both U.S. stocks and high-yield bonds (in orange) is plotted below and to the right of a similar portfolio using Treasuries bonds (in blue). Or said another way, when you use Treasuries instead of high-yield bonds, you can get a higher return while enduring less risk (or at least that has been the case historically). In short, using high-yield bonds when paired with stocks to create a diversified portfolio may be a poor decision – at least if the goal is to generate a superior risk-adjusted return (and it should be!).

Look at Investments as Part of a Diversified Portfolio

The lesson is this: the next time you’re considering the merit of an investment (be it junk bonds, cryptocurrency, marijuana stocks, the newest hedge fund, or any new-nesss), consider not just the investment itself. Evaluate how that investment’s performance impacts the total of all your investments. This is modern portfolio theory at work!

(Disclaimer: This is not investment advice. The blog post is for entertainment purposes only.)

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Is a One-Day Financial Review Right for You?

Get Your Free Assessment ➔

Get in Touch with Jon Luskin, CFP®

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Sign Up for New Blog Posts & Podcasts Delivered to Your Inbox

What I’m Reading Right Now

Recent Posts

  • Bogleheads® Live 37: Christine Benz on ‘How much can I spend in retirement?’
  • Bogleheads® Live 36: Mike Piper on ‘After the Death of Your Spouse’
  • Bogleheads® Live 35: Bill Bengen on the 4% Rule of Thumb
  • Bogleheads® Live 34: Cameron Huddleston on talking to your parents about their finances
  • Bogleheads® Live 33: Colleen Jaconetti on Rebalancing Your Portfolio

Categories

  • Bogleheads® Live
  • Bonds
  • Financial Planning
  • FIRE, FI, Early Retirement
  • Investing
  • Practice Management
  • Real Estate Investing
  • Tax Planning

Jon Luskin, CFP® Follow

Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors. '@Bogleheads® Live' host. Advice-Only #CFP®. #fiduciary. @SDFLC volunteer. Tweets ≠ Advice. https://t.co/GJqMxem3Cr

JonLuskin
Retweet on Twitter Jon Luskin, CFP® Retweeted
bogleheads John C Bogle Center for Financial Literacy @bogleheads ·
5h

Taylor Larimore, one of the original Bogleheads and a living legend, celebrated his 99th birthday on Wednesday.

Happy birthday, dear Taylor, and thank you for your service! You inspire us to live well, help others, and be kind. Sign Taylor's "card" here: https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=395758

Reply on Twitter 1618725218478071814 Retweet on Twitter 1618725218478071814 3 Like on Twitter 1618725218478071814 33 Twitter 1618725218478071814
jonluskin Jon Luskin, CFP® @jonluskin ·
5h

"Back-door Roth IRA" is a verb, not a noun.

It's a process for high earners to get money into Roth IRA accounts, offering tax-free growth.

#investing #taxes

Reply on Twitter 1618715442821963798 Retweet on Twitter 1618715442821963798 3 Like on Twitter 1618715442821963798 6 Twitter 1618715442821963798
Retweet on Twitter Jon Luskin, CFP® Retweeted
iraownersmanual IRA Owner's Manual @iraownersmanual ·
13h

Bogleheads® Live with Bill Bengen: Episode 35 #PFshare via @JonLuskin https://boglecenter.net/bogleheads-live-with-bill-bengen-episode-35/

Reply on Twitter 1618601426103533570 Retweet on Twitter 1618601426103533570 1 Like on Twitter 1618601426103533570 Twitter 1618601426103533570
Load More

Is the One-Day Financial Review right for you?


Get Your Free Assessment ➔

Disclosures & Legal

Jon Luskin is a registered investment adviser in the states of Arizona, California, Florida, Louisiana, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Texas, Virginia and Washington. The Adviser may not transact business in states where it is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration. Currently, there are no states where the adviser is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration – allowing the adviser to work with anyone in any state. Individualized responses to persons that involve either the effecting of transaction in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation, will not be made without registration or exemption.

Copyright © 2023