• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Jon Luskin, CFP® ● Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors

Hourly Advice for Do-It-Yourself Investors

  • Home
  • About
  • Work with Jon
  • Blog
  • Bogleheads® Live
  • Publications
  • Reading List

Rental Real Estate Investing Across the United States

June 26, 2020 By Jon Luskin 1 Comment

Previously, I wrote that stock market investing has historically outperformed rental real estate investing in California. (This is even the case when considering leverage: California rental property underperforms the stock market.) This conclusion applies not just to real estate in California, but anywhere with dense populations. This is because high population density creates a high demand for real estate (relative to less densely-populated areas).

This increased demand for housing pushes up real estate prices. All else being equal, higher housing prices drive down the investment return available on area rental real estate. (The investment return calculation (%) of a rental property uses the property acquisition price as the denominator.)

All else being equal, the higher the acquisition cost for a rental property, the lower your investment return.

The above does consider that increased rent can be had in more populous areas. However, while rent is indeed higher for more expensive properties, rent prices do not increase proportionally with the cost of real estate in larger cities. Said technically: across the country, the standard deviation in rent is less than the standard deviation of the prices of single-family homes. Rent prices lag property prices.

Let’s use an example to drive the point home: consider that while a single-family home in San Diego, California can cost twenty times that of a single-family home in Marion, Indiana, you cannot charge 20 times in rent for the San Diego home. One could not even charge half that – ten times. Considering only cash flow – and not appreciation – this means that the return on your California rental will be (relatively) less profitable.

City/MetricSan Diego, CAMarion, IN
Home Price~$550,000~$26,500
Rent, Monthly~$3,300~$650
Home prices vary more than rent across the country. While a home in San Diego, CA can cost twenty times that of a home in Marion, Indiana, you cannot charge 20 times in rent for the San Diego home.

Thus, we’ve now argued that not only is California rental real estate less profitable than stock market investing (even when including leverage), but higher-priced rental properties are also less profitable than less expensive rental real estate in other parts of the country – where single-family homes can be had for less money.

Quick Tangent

Why do home prices vary so dramatically over rent prices? Leverage. One cannot take out a loan to pay rent – but they certainly can to buy a home. With leverage, individuals can buy things they otherwise could not afford. This means homes can be sold for more. Were mortgages not a thing, housing prices would come crashing down. Imagine how inexpensive homes would have to be if all buyers had to pay cash! Without a way to finance rent, rent is only as high as tenants have cash flow for it.

So, what do you think? Where are your real estate investments? How do you advise your clients on real estate investing?

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Is a One-Day Financial Review Right for You?

Get Your Free Assessment ➔

Get in Touch with Jon Luskin, CFP®

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Sign Up for New Blog Posts & Podcasts Delivered to Your Inbox

What I’m Reading Now

Recent Posts

  • Bogleheads on Investing 58: Mike Piper on “More than Enough”
  • Bogleheads® Live 44: Mr. Money Mustache – Early Retirement (FIRE)
  • Bogleheads® Live 43: Cybersecurity with Steve Ryder – Keeping Your Money Safe Online
  • Bogleheads® Live 42: How to Pay for College with Ann Garcia
  • April Fools’

Categories

  • Bogleheads® Live
  • Bonds
  • College Planning
  • Financial Planning
  • FIRE, FI, Early Retirement
  • Investing
  • Practice Management
  • Real Estate Investing
  • Tax Planning

Is the One-Day Financial Review right for you?


Get Your Free Assessment ➔

Disclosures & Legal

Jon Luskin is a registered investment adviser in the states of Arizona, California, Florida, Louisiana, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Texas, Virginia and Washington. The Adviser may not transact business in states where it is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration. Currently, there are no states where the adviser is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration – allowing the adviser to work with anyone in any state. Individualized responses to persons that involve either the effecting of transaction in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation, will not be made without registration or exemption.

Copyright © 2023